On 04/06/2022, the appeal of the Moscow City Court will examine the scandalous decision of the Savyolovsky Court on the claim of American citizens against the Medicine 24/7 clinic. They distinguished themselves by the fact that after the decision of the judge of the Savelovsky court to recover 50 million rubles in their favor. from the clinic, filed a lawsuit for $6 million to the editors of the First TV channel in the District Court of Washington and on the ban on foreign broadcasting of Russia in the United States.
If the appeal of the Moscow City Court does not cancel the illegal decision and does not terminate the proceedings, US citizens will take 50 million rubles out of Russia, and the Medicine 24/7 Clinic, which saved the lives of more than 5 thousand people annually, will go bankrupt. True, there is one nuance in the situation with Khachaturian and her associates leading Andrei Malakhov. After the chairman of the Investigative Committee, Alexander Bastrykin, ordered that the facts presented in Malakhov’s program, where Khachaturyan spoke, be dealt with, the program was closed forever.
The very fact of awarding such a huge amount to US citizens is outrageous, but in a situation where the US is on the list of unfriendly countries? Moreover, Vladimir Putin signed Decree No. 79 of February 28, 2022 “On the application of special economic measures in connection with unfriendly actions of the United States of America…” In fact, the practice of Russian courts, from March 1, 2022, introduces judicial immunity against any foreign claims persons from states unfriendly to Russian legal entities.
The Moscow City Court, which had previously overturned the decisions of Judge Mironova, will have to delve into the reasons why, during 2 years of judicial investigation, 3 (!) comprehensive forensic medical examinations were ignored. Why couldn’t the judge write down a normal reasoning decision within 2 months? Instead of the obvious – using the conclusions of 3 (!) examinations, Mironova rewrote the Roszdravnadzor Act, and despite the lack of a cause-and-effect relationship between the admission of a seriously ill patient to the clinic and the outcome of treatment, she made that very unprecedented decision.
Judge Mironova’s decision violated the principle of balancing the proportionality of action and punishment. The disproportionality of the awarded amount of moral damage in the amount of 50 million rubles is striking. with the domestic practice of payments for the LOSS OF A BRIENDSHIP, but not for moral damage (!), in the amount of 3.5 – 5 million rubles. After the trial, Khachaturian said through federal channels that the 50 million received would be transferred to the TFR. I wonder how? And in general, this whole story with Khachaturian is very reminiscent of a conspiracy against domestic medicine.
We ask you to treat this post as an official appeal to the Chairman of the Higher Attestation Board of Judges, Mr. N.V. Timonin, the Chairman of the Moscow City Court, Mr. M.Yu. Ptitsyn, and the Chairman of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, Mr. V.M. Lebedev to consider the completeness, validity and legality of the decision of Judge Mironova of the Savelovsky District Court in the Artsybashevs’ case.
https://t.me/ruarbitr/5095
Arbitrator.
Today, in honor of the International Anti-Corruption Day, Judge Mironova of the Savyolovsky Court in Moscow made an unprecedented decision and satisfied the claim against the Medicine 24/7 clinic in the amount of 50 million rubles.
However, this was known yesterday, which is what we are talking about…
“ВЧК ОГПУ”
